Zillow's Preview program now channels pre-market listings exclusively through Zillow and Realtor.com before those homes reach the MLS. A November 2026 HousingWire opinion piece by Carter Dougherty, Senior Fellow at Demand Progress, argues that this arrangement raises antitrust questions federal and state regulators have not yet examined. Here is what the program does, what the concerns are, and what it means for buyers and sellers.
What Zillow Preview is
Zillow launched Preview in March 2026 with more than 400 brokerages and franchisors, including Keller Williams, REMAX and HomeServices of America. Participating agents can display listings on Zillow before submitting them to the local MLS. In May 2026, Zillow extended the arrangement so that Preview listings also appear on Realtor.com.
The two portals together account for approximately 75% of major U.S. real estate portal traffic, according to a figure the companies themselves cited in a May 2026 press release. That means competing platforms—Homes.com, Redfin and smaller portals—do not see those listings during the preview window.
Zillow's argument for the program
Zillow has said the program brings pre-market listings into the open rather than leaving them in private agent networks. The company's chief industry development officer, Errol Samuelson, told HousingWire at launch that brokers had been "pre-marketing those listings, but putting them behind a gate and using them as a way to attract buyer to work exclusively with their company" — and that over time, he believes that approach "is fundamentally damaging for the real estate market." Gary Keller, executive chairman and co-founder of Keller Williams, said in the same report: "We believe an open market serves consumers the best."
That argument is not frivolous. When a listing sits in a private network—visible only to one brokerage's clients—the seller loses exposure and buyers outside that network never see the home. Moving those listings to a large public portal is a step toward broader visibility.
The antitrust questions
Dougherty's HousingWire piece raises a different concern: even if Preview is more open than a pocket listing, it still channels early inventory through two dominant platforms to the exclusion of every other portal and agent network. He writes that "a dominant firm signing up hundreds of suppliers to exclusive early access should raise concerns," particularly when the same firm monetizes every pageview and pays listing agents a share of the buyer-side commission on deals closed through its aligned agents.
Dougherty also points to the recent FTC and state attorney general settlement involving Zillow's rental listings market, in which regulators alleged Zillow paid a competitor to stop advertising rental listings. He argues the residential sales market—where roughly four million homes change hands each year—deserves the same scrutiny.
These are allegations and policy arguments, not settled law. Courts and regulators will determine whether the program crosses any legal line. But the questions themselves are worth understanding.
Why this matters if you are buying or selling a home
For sellers: a pre-market listing on Zillow reaches a large audience, but it does not reach every audience. Buyers who search through other platforms, through their own agent's MLS access, or through local brokerage networks will not see your home during the preview window. Whether that tradeoff benefits a seller depends on the property, the market and the marketing plan—not on a blanket assumption that early Zillow exposure is always better than full MLS exposure from day one.
For buyers: if you rely on a single portal for your home search, you may be seeing a curated version of the market. The MLS remains the most comprehensive source of active listings. A buyer's agent with direct MLS access can show you homes that have not yet appeared on any portal, as well as homes that appeared on one portal but not the one you use.
My view
I have been a managing broker for 19 years. I wrote earlier this year that selling private real estate listings as a general strategy is, in my opinion, a breach of fiduciary duty. That view has not changed. Open markets protect consumers. Closed systems protect insiders.
Zillow Preview is not a closed system in the way a pocket listing is. It publishes listings where millions of people can see them. But "more open than a pocket listing" is not the same as "fully open." An arrangement that gives two platforms exclusive early access while locking out every competitor still limits who gets to see a home and when. Whether that serves the seller's interest or the platform's interest is a question every seller should ask before opting in.
The antitrust questions Dougherty raises deserve attention. So does a simpler question every agent and broker can answer right now: does the marketing plan you are recommending serve your client, or does it serve the platform?
Sources: HousingWire, Carter Dougherty, Nov. 2026; HousingWire, Zillow Preview launch, March 2026; HousingWire, Realtor.com syndication, May 2026.